The title of this article was not written to be clickbait, but a genuine question—a refrain even—that I had in my mind. As a mid-career professional who had been building a career in one organisation over the last decade or so, I often wondered about my growth potential within and beyond the organisation; something that I was fortunate to be able to discuss openly with my reporting managers throughout the years.
However, could I call them my mentors as well? I certainly did. Some of them have even been my champions, advocating for me in rooms that I could not personally be in. Even so, a reporting relationship can be complex, delicate, and layered with power distance. Even the best of us might wonder how much we can really share with someone who has a direct impact on our performance evaluation and bonuses. In those situations, the guidance of a mentor outside of the organisation might have been comforting.
This is where the process gets hazy: how does one find a suitable mentor, and what does an aspiring mentee need to do? Most importantly, does mentorship even work, or is it just glorified networking?
Mentorship as a Concept
Sometimes described almost as an all-purpose balm, a mentor in a professional context is typically understood as someone with more experience, and generally, sager. Having walked a path before us, they can provide us with insights, direction and clarity that might otherwise take decades to gain. Not to conflate experience with age – a mentor can also be someone biologically younger than we are.1
As a current student in the National University of Singapore (NUS) Master of Communication (formerly known as Master of Social Sciences (Communication)) programme, I read with great interest that the programme offered a mentorship component, where we could be matched with senior industry leaders who would advise us on our professional goals. Leaders would be thoroughly vetted, and an academic coordinator would search for suitable mentors to match us with. The structure, rigour of mentor vetting, and the relief at not having to navigate a sea of potential mentors myself, piqued my curiosity. So, I applied.
Finding “the One”
This next question is a little less overwhelming than if I were choosing my life partner, but still rings true: even if I get matched, how do I really know that my mentor is “the one”? As with all important questions, I would like to think that the search starts with introspection on what I am trying to achieve. For me, it took a quiet afternoon of freewheeling writing, and watching my career spill out onto paper. That enabled me to identify broad themes in my experience and gain clarity on growth areas I would like a mentor to guide me on. Finding “the one” first requires gleaning a sense of oneself and what one stands for.
With this knowledge, our academic coordinator eventually matched me with a mentor whom I have been able to openly discuss my dreams and worries with. The process gave rise to new insights, offered me unbridled feedback and most importantly, a safe environment and the knowledge that I was not alone. Surely, I could have done this with a trusted friend or loved one too, but remember: the views of our loved ones can sometimes come with preconceived notions about who we used to be, instead of what we are hoping to be. This is not always a true indicator of what else one may go on to achieve, which a third-party mentor might just offer a refreshing perspective on.
From left to right: Ms Nicole Ong, Mentor from the MOC Mentorship Programme and Ms Bell Yeo, Author
Does Mentorship Really Work, and Is It Only for Early Career Professionals?
There is ample evidence that mentorship is not just a fable. Real people with real lives succeed, and make better, informed decisions due to a mentor’s guidance.2, 3 Even in research, it has been proven that mentoring relationships help “to build knowledge and skills, develop networking opportunities, build confidence and gain self-reflection abilities” (Scerri et al., 2020).4
When I applied for mentorship, I had some intriguing peer conversations around themes of “I would rather learn from professors to maximise my school fees”. I empathise with this view. However, to relegate an industry mentor’s lived experiences as lesser than those of esteemed academics would be a gross oversight. The advice of a well-matched mentor is just as valuable as a professor’s, if not more so, for life is lived in the real world. If Steve Jobs, Oprah Winfrey, and Yves Saint Laurent all had mentors throughout their illustrious careers, we certainly need industry mentors alongside academic knowledge—and at every point in our career.
Mentorship as an End-All-and-Be-All
So, is a mentor the answer to all our career insecurities, trials and tribulations? Probably not, for our mentors are also human. However, they will serve as a valuable sounding board for us to uncover the answers that are already within. Call it career therapy, if you will—for the best answers are those that are authentically ours. In a world where everyone is trying to tell us what to think, arguably the most precious trait we can develop is a sense of who we are, even in the careers we choose.
This is the part where I confess to having a Note on my iPhone chock-full of motivational lines, which I occasionally whip out to glance through during a particularly difficult day, picking whichever one would act as a salve for an aching mind (and sometimes, heart). I did this in a physical notebook when I was just 10 and just discovering the wonders of journaling, thinking that I would be better at this when I grew up. Some 20 years later, I am still growing up. Feeling lost sometimes is still a familiar friend.
So, I end by sharing a line from the poem Invictus, by William Ernest Henley, that sits in this very iPhone Note, which has energised me on more than one occasion whenever I felt lost: “I am the master of my fate; I am the captain of my soul”.
Everyone has a mentor, or it certainly seems like they do—and you can “get” one too, but remember, your best mentor ultimately, is you. Everyone else is just along for the ride.
REFERENCES
- Yeoh, G. (2021). IN FOCUS: Can good mentorship at work lead to a more fulfilling career - and life? CNA.
https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/focus-mentorship-companies-career-workplace-work-2203076 - Chan, D. (2022). How a mentor can reshape your career. Her World Singapore.
https://www.herworld.com/life/how-a-mentor-can-reshape-your-career/ - Theseira, J. C. (2022). How mentoring helps these youth to overcome hurdles and progress further. The Straits Times.
https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/how-mentoring-helps-these-youth-to-overcome-hurdles-and-progress-further - Scerri, M., Presbury, R., & Goh, E. (2020). An application of the mentoring framework to investigate the effectiveness of mentoring programs between industry mentors and student mentees in hospitality. Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Management, 45, 143–151.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhtm.2020.08.010